Earlier this week we met with officials from HM Treasury who are leading the Government’s eVED consultation. We shared our analysis of the proposals and discussed the cross-border driving issues unique to Northern Ireland.

The following points are taken from our official consultation submission. We have also included findings from our recent member survey, alongside a sample of comments from respondents.


Unfair Flat Rate, No Efficiency Flexibility
The proposed eVED system is unfair because it is not truly equivalent to fuel duty. Fuel duty can be reduced by choosing a more efficient vehicle or driving more gently. By contrast, eVED is a flat per-mile charge that can only be lowered by driving less, making it a more rigid and punitive tax on mobility itself while disincentivising efficiency.

Hits Rural, Care Workers, Long Commuters Hardest
The proposal would also disproportionately harm those who have the least flexibility in their travel needs, including rural residents, carers and people with long commutes who cannot realistically reduce their mileage.

Penalises NI Drivers Travelling in RoI
Northern Ireland drivers face particular unfairness. Many motorists regularly drive in the Republic of Ireland yet would still be taxed by the UK on those miles, despite using roads funded by another jurisdiction. In border communities, most driving may take place outside the UK, making the charge especially inequitable.

One-Off Payments Would Hit Worst Off Hardest
The planned system of prepayment is also less fair than fuel duty. Petrol and diesel drivers pay tax in small amounts spread across the year, while EV drivers could face large upfront bills based on estimated mileage. This harms household cash flow, forces motorists to predict uncertain future travel, risks overpayment or penalties, and effectively provides the government with an interest-free loan.

Uncertainty on Business Mileage Rates?
There is also uncertainty about business mileage fairness. If EV drivers must pay additional per-mile taxation, it is unclear whether the government will increase approved mileage allowance rates so those extra costs can be reclaimed. EVs currently attract lower reimbursement rates than petrol and diesel vehicles, so without adjustment, business users could be financially penalised for choosing electric.

MOT at Year 4 in NI vs Year 3 in GB
If proposals rely on annual MOT tests to verify mileage, they would create regional difference. In Northern Ireland, where vehicles require their first MOT at year 4, compared with year 3 in Great Britain. Using MOT records as the basis for mileage verification would therefore produce inconsistent treatment between regions.

Confusion
Many drivers believe the proposed new charge is an additional road tax – EV owners already pay standard VED (vehicle excise duty). The policy is intended to replace fuel duty, but calling it eVED links it to ‘Road Tax’ and risks ongoing misunderstanding. Additionally, as the comments below show, everyone has heard all about the proposed 3p per mile, but not the proposed fuel duty rises. The Government needs to do much better around this messaging.

Summary

The proposed pay-per-mile tax for electric vehicles risks becoming a major own-goal for the EV transition. It is being presented as a replacement for fuel duty, but it isn’t equivalent. Fuel duty can be reduced by driving efficiently or choosing a smaller vehicle, whereas a flat per-mile charge can only be reduced by driving less. That makes it a blunt tax on mobility itself and removes any incentive for efficiency. It will also fall hardest on people who have the least flexibility in how much they drive, rural residents, carers and long-distance commuters. For many of them, mileage isn’t a choice, it’s a necessity. On top of that, the proposal to collect the charge through pre-payments creates further unfairness, forcing drivers to estimate their future mileage and potentially pay large lump sums up front, unlike petrol and diesel drivers who pay tax gradually at the pump.

The issue is particularly acute in Northern Ireland, where many motorists regularly drive in the Republic of Ireland. Under the proposal they would still pay UK mileage tax on those journeys, even though they are using roads funded by another country. There are also unanswered questions about how business drivers will be treated, given that EVs currently receive lower mileage reimbursement rates than petrol or diesel vehicles. Without changes, people who use EVs for work could end up financially worse off. Even the practical details raise problems, for example if mileage verification relies on MOT records, the system would treat Northern Ireland differently because vehicles there are first tested at year four rather than year three as in Great Britain. Taken together, these issues are already creating confusion and discouraging EV adoption. Many drivers feel they were encouraged to switch to electric and are now being penalised for doing so, which risks slowing the very transition the government says it wants to accelerate.

While the government rightly says fuel duty receipts have already fallen, that’s not due to EVs, which currently make up just 5% of cars on UK roads. Receipts have fallen because successive governments have used fuel-duty freezes to protect drivers from the impact of fuel price inflation. The fall in duty is a result of political choices and is not a sound basis on which to introduce a new tax that singles out a technology that is still in the early stages of adoption and critical to meeting our climate targets.


Survey Results

Our eVED survey was held over 5 days in mid March 2026 and had 189 responses. Read on for the results, along with a selection of comments that are representative of the themes raised.

Question 1: Do You support the introduction of a mileage-based tax on BEVs?

  1. No – 55.1%
  2. Yes, but too early – 29.4%
  3. Unsure – 11.2%
  4. Yes – 4.4%

Question 2: The current proposals include all mileage, including trips outside the UK (for example to the Republic of Ireland or Europe). How much of your BEV driving is outside the UK?

  • Yes Occasionally – 39.2%
  • Yes 10% of Mileage – 19.6%
  • Yes 11-30% of Mileage – 17.5%
  • No – 15.9%
  • Yes more than 51% of Mileage – 5.3%
  • Yes 31-50% of Mileage – 2.6%

Question 3: Mileage reporting is proposed to be at the time of taxing a car, to be estimated and paid for in advance. Would you prefer;

1. Pay monthly for actual mileage driven – report at the end of month – 69.4%
2. Pay yearly in advance – estimate mileage – 26.3%
3. Pay monthly in advance – estimate mileage – 4.3%  


Question 4: the government has proposed mileage reporting yearly, and has ruled out an electronic means of managing mileage as potentially invading privacy. However would the following options be preferrable?

  1. Yearly reporting at VED tax renewal only – 49.7%
  2. Optional app or web portal monthly manual reporting of mileage (similar to reporting of an electricity meter readings to an energy provider) – 36.9%
  3. Optional app-based reporting of all actual mileage by GPS – 10.2%
  4. Optional black box automatic reporting all actual mileage by GPS – 3.2%

Question 5: Any other thoughts on the eVED proposals?

  • It’s uncalled for saying as our tax is now 195 when some ice cars polluting the planet are £30, I love my EV and reducing my carbon footprint but it feels like the government is trying to punish this after advising it.
  • We’ve been told for years that car tax was based on carbon emissions. I have a full bev that is £195 per year plus this eVED when it comes in. I have 10 year old diesel that costs £20 per year. Ridiculous.
  • For high mileage drivers like myself (15,000 miles per year) I can say these proposals will impact my decision to keep my EV or sell and revert to a ICE.
  • Unfair to pay road tax for driving on roads in Republic of Ireland. This needs taken into account
  • I mainly drive in ROI but live in NI.
  • I drive 80% on Irish roads where I pay the tolls, now I’ve to pay UK government as well to drive on Irish roads. Yet visitors from Ireland or other countries to UK pay nothing. That’s all wrong.
  • I was about to buy an electric car when the announcement of the mileage based tax system came into conversation. I do about 25,000 miles per year and about 20,000 are in the Republic of Ireland. I live in Northern Ireland. My fear is that it would be 3p in year 1, 6p in year 2, etc. I didn’t buy the electric car and I still use my diesel vehicle due to the mileage based tax putting me off. My tax bill is fixed for a diesel vehicle and it is variable for an ev.
  • They promoted this as the future then they punish us for it. My Vauxhall EV is more to tax than my colleagues Volvo despite mine being emission free.
  • Another government tax, im thinking of changing from electric to a phev.
  • Massive potential to push people back to ICE.
  • Likely to reduce demand for further EV adoption.
  • It’s bizarre to introduce this tax when the government want to encourage people to move to ev
  • It’s too early for EVs and gives mixed messages to potential purchasers. Should be implemented for all cars at the same time.
  • Told us all to move to EV then look for ways to penalise us after we do the ‘right thing’
  • It’s going to put off some many people from changing to EV.
  • Reduce the amount. 3p doesn’t sound a lot but I do 30k miles just getting to and from work. So going to be a big chunk. I might have to reconsider leaving my job.
  • I would seriously consider switching back to petrol of diesel – I pay just as much to run the car as my son who drives a diesel car and he isn’t worried about infrastructure when it comes to charging etc – I drive about 500 miles a month so I would be paying £15 per month on top of all my regular costs including annual tax which is now £195. It is hard to see what the benefit to me is of driving an EV car.
  • Seems like a tax on rural living.
  • This discriminates against people who do not live in cities and who therefore need to drive longer distances for their daily lives or who will not have access to viable public transport.
  • Open to widespread cheating.
  • There is a severe negative psychological effect of charging a few pence per mile, which is outweighing the discounts available when buying some new EVs.
  • eVED should not be introduced at all. If we are to meet our net zero targets, more people need to be incentivised into driving full EV cars, not taxed for doing so.
  • Not at all sure this is a good idea. I always thought that if a pay per mile system came in it would replace ved, and not be an additional tax. If the government are serious about the transition to zero emission vehicles, then I think that is just another reason for people to resist changing.
  • I feel let down by this approach. Encouraged to go green and then sucker punched to pay more.
  • The government should consider scrapping pay-per-mile until EVs make up at least 50% of all new car sales.
  • Proposal is incompatible with Climate Change commitments and promoting uptake to alternative low emission vehicles.
  • Another example of UK government approach to electric vehicle owners. Rather than tax owners why aren’t there more incentives to encourage the shift from fossil fuel to BEV as happens in other European countries and Norway for example.
  • Appalling idea. We should be encouraging people – not discouraged them to drive electric cars
  • The government should be encouraging the switch to EV but every step they make discourages it.
Category
Tags

No responses yet

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.