I really liked my 2018 Mercedes C-Class diesel – comfortable, well built, reliable, attractive and with a great interior and features. And because I usually buy cars privately I’ve tended to keep them for 5-8 years, so was quite content I’d be driving it for a long time.
And then, hmm, well a work opportunity came up, I was reviewing my finances and there was an option of a new car lease and an employer keen to promote a move to EVs among staff. A salary sacrifice scheme meant I could lease it and take the benefit of just 1% BIK (Benefit in Kind). Maybe I could make a change?
Buying
In May 2021 I booked a test drive with Tesla, partly to see what the fuss was about and because my 18-year-old daughter thought it would be cool. It was still post lockdown so they just gave us the car and said come back in an hour.
Now I knew Tesla’s and EVs were quick, but my god was I in for a shock. As I took off up the M1 from the Balls on the Falls towards Dunmurry I was at the speed limit (honest no more officer) before I knew it with a big smile growing on my face. My daughter was meanwhile playing with the touch screen display and turning on fart mode – well we were just having a bit of fun, weren’t we?
An hour later we’re back at the service centre and I’m discussing what they have available to order before the end of June, finance options and apologising for not knowing how to turn off the fart mode for the next test driver.
The Tesla 3 Long Range I picked is pretty much the same size as any mid-range saloon and practically speaking it suits our family needs with the 18-year-old away off to college. I was surprised that the leasing cost was comparable to a new Mercedes C-class, but the BIK tax benefit made it a no brainer, and of course with a home charging option the fuel costs were estimated to be at least a 50% reduction.
Day to Day Use – Range & Charging
We got a charger installed at the house (yes you will need access to off road parking so I know that won’t suit everyone) and with access to chargers at my workplace too I was all set to go. The range anxiety lasted about 2 months while I got confident with how to charge it, tried out public chargers as a backup and stopped obsessively watching the remaining range read out.
I have a daily work commute of 36 miles round trip of the worst hell in NI – A1 Hillsborough Roundabout, Sprucefield, M1, Westlink, M2 to Dargan. All but 1 mile of it motorway. It recently took 1 hour 27 minutes due to a single broken down car at the Carlisle circus off slip. The day before I went to central Dublin in 1 hour 28 minutes, but this isn’t a blog about DfI Roads so let me move on.

I normally travel around 300 miles per week. The range on the Tesla is 325 miles and it really does depend on how you drive so I probably don’t get that very often. A better way to look at it is that on average it’s about 5 days between plugging in for a charge. That’s partly because I charge when between 10-20% left in the battery and up to 80% to protect the battery condition. If I’m planning a longer journey I’ll bang it up to 100% without issue. Generally it’s overnight at home while I’m asleep and maybe a couple of times a month at the office when I know it’s going to be sitting for the day, or I have a long work journey to do the next day. I use public chargers very occasionally for longer journeys but that would be when the location is more than 120 miles from home, which really isn’t often. I’ve barely been in a petrol station in 3 years – I don’t think I’m missing much.
I’ve had to buy 2 sets of tyres with the original set lasting 28K miles. And with regenerative braking I’ve haven’t had to change brake pads or discs. The Tesla only has an interim service check for a cabin air filter so mechanically it has proven to be much simpler than the service requirements of my previous Mercedes.
I’ve driven the car to Cork, Donegal, West Tyrone, 3 times to Scotland on top of my ‘regular’ driving which includes Dublin once a month. I promise you it is straightforward and the public charger infrastructure is so much better than it was 3 years ago when I started.
Misinformation
The naysayers continue to be out in force and the misinformation seems to be getting worse – who is funding this I wonder. The stories about people handing back 3 month old Jaguars because they couldn’t drive to Dublin and back are just Shaggy Dog stories. It amazes me that we’ve turned a form of energy moving a car into a culture war issue. Maybe it’s just people don’t like being told what to do, but then nobody is saying everyone must move to an EV by next Tuesday. If you want to drive a diesel for the next decade then knock yourself out, no one is stopping you. All that will happen is that you’ll waste a bunch of money and probably have less fun. And don’t bother waiting for Hydrogen, they aren’t coming anytime soon so you should pick the best option that actually exists today.
What’s Next?
In three and a half years I’ve settled into a straightforward routine, it has suited my day to day needs and I’ve never run out of charge though I have been close a couple of times. In comparison to a petrol diesel equivalent I’ve saved money and the car has been fun to drive every day. Plenty of people will say it won’t work for them and for some that may well be true, but I’ve found the transition pretty seamless, and the benefits have all materialised. So if you’re planning to change your car I can whole heartedly recommend an electric powered one. What’s next for me is of course another EV or a new ‘vehicle’ as it seems it would be easier to just call it – I mean who cares whether it runs on electric rather than petrol as long as it works for me?
There are so many more options available now than in 2021 – Mercedes, BMW, BYD, Volkswagen, Hyundai etc. Loads of mainstream brands with an average range of circa 300 miles. And while I’ll still use my home charger for most of the time there are an amazing number of new public charging stations spreading across the country to support EV ownership day to day.
Ultimately, I know that an EV is a practical and financially sensible option for me, so the decision boils down to an emotional one around what I like the look of, which is good place to be. The big issue is how I convince my wife that buying another Tesla doesn’t mean we have to vote for Elon.
By Michael Thompson

One response
Very good, a true honest opinion, I liked the reading about the the various trips which most motorists might be drive. The last statement is so true “convince my wife that buying a Tesla doesn’t mean we have to vote for Elon”